Pricing Decisions
What a discount must earn back, who you can lose after a price rise, and bottleneck hours.
In your head, jot if needed · no calculator why?
Opens at level 18. You're level 1. You can read and practice here now.
the idea
A discount comes straight out of contribution, since each sale's variable cost stays the same. At a $100 price and $60 variable cost, a 10% discount cuts contribution from $40 to $30, so sales must rise by a third to earn the same total.
After a price rise, you can lose some customers and still keep total contribution; that count is a limit, not a forecast. When hours are the bottleneck, rank jobs by contribution per scarce hour. The most revenue is not always the most profit.
techniques
Take the discount out of contribution
- New price: take the discount off the price.
- New contribution: new price minus variable cost.
- To keep total contribution, sales must rise by old ÷ new contribution, minus 1.
worked example
Price is $50 and variable cost is $30. After a 10% discount, by what percentage must sales volume rise to keep the same total contribution? Round to one decimal place.
- Old contribution: $50 − $30 = $20.
- At the new $45 price: $45 − $30 = $15.
- $20 ÷ $15 ≈ 1.333, a rise of about 33.3%.
Answer: 33.3%
Customers you must keep
- Total contribution now: customers × contribution each.
- Divide by the new contribution per customer.
- Round up: that many must stay.
worked example
30 customers each contribute $200. A price rise would lift that to $260 each. How many whole customers must stay to keep at least $6,000 of contribution?
- $6,000 ÷ $260 ≈ 23.08.
- Round up to 24: 23 customers bring only $5,980.
Answer: 24
Compare on profit, or per hour
- For each option: units × (price − variable cost) − fixed costs.
- When hours are the limit, divide each job's contribution by its scarce hours instead.
- Pick the highest, not the most revenue or the biggest total.
worked example
Price $40, variable cost $25, fixed costs $2,000 a month, 200 units now. Option 1: raise the price to $45 and sell 170 units. By how much does Option 1 raise operating profit?
- Now: 200 × ($40 − $25) − $2,000 = $1,000.
- Option 1: 170 × ($45 − $25) − $2,000 = $1,400.
- Profit rises by $400, even though revenue falls.
Answer: $400
watch out for
- Taking the discount off the contribution instead of off the price.
- Assuming a 10% price cut needs only 10% more sales.
- Rounding the customers you must keep down, which falls short of the old total.
- Choosing the job with the bigger total, or the option with more revenue.
practice
Contribution after a discount
worked example
Price is $280 and variable cost is $125. A 5% price discount is offered. What is the new contribution per sale?
Answer: $141.00
- New price = $280 × 0.95 = $266; contribution = $266 − $125 = $141, down from $155.
- The whole $14 discount comes out of contribution.
Extra volume a discount needs
worked example
Price is $300 and variable cost is $240. After a 5% discount, by what percentage must sales volume rise to keep the same total contribution? Round to one decimal place if needed.
Answer: 33.3%
- Contribution per sale falls from $300 − $240 = $60 to $285 − $240 = $45.
- Volume must rise by $60 ÷ $45 − 1 ≈ 33.3%.
Price rise: customers you must keep
worked example
98 customers each contribute $470. A price increase would raise contribution to $560 per customer. What is the minimum whole number of customers needed to keep at least $46,060 of contribution?
Answer: 83
- $46,060 ÷ $560 = 82.25; round up to 83.
- This is a threshold, not a forecast of how many will stay.
Contribution per scarce hour
worked example
Job A contributes $620 in 4 scarce work hours. Job B contributes $1,400 in 7 scarce work hours. Which earns more contribution per scarce hour?
- Job B
- They are equal
- Job A
- You need the selling prices to decide
Answer: Job B
- Per hour: A = $620 ÷ 4 = $155; B = $1,400 ÷ 7 = $200.
- When hours are the limit, rank jobs by contribution per scarce hour (assuming there's enough demand).
Which price makes the most profit?
worked example
Price $85, variable cost $38 per unit, fixed costs $12,000 a month, 455 units a month now, capacity 590 units. Option 1: raise the price to $92 and sell 410 units. Option 2: cut the price to $80 and sell 554 units. Which gives the highest monthly operating profit?
- Option 1 (raise price)
- All three are equal
- Keep the current price
- Option 2 (cut price)
Answer: Option 2 (cut price)
- Profit = units × (price − variable) − fixed: now $9,385, Option 1 $10,140, Option 2 $11,268.